| 1 | Russell “Bull” Behman | Guard | Dickinson |
| 1 | Benjamin Jones | Fullback / Blocking Back / Tail Back / Wing Back | Grove City College |
| 2 | Les Haws | Blocking Back | Dartmouth |
| 2 | William “Link” Lyman | Tackle | Nebraska |
| 3 | Ernest “Tex” Hamer | Wing Back | Pennsylvania |
| 4 | George Sullivan | Tail Back | Pennsylvania |
| 5 | Paul “Bob” Fitzke | Wing Back | Idaho |
| 6 | Houston Stockton | Fullback | Gonzaga |
| 7 | Anthony “Tony” Wilsbach | Guard | Bucknell |
| 7 | George “Bull” Lowe | End | Fordham |
| 8 | Henry “Two-Bits” Homan | Blocking Back | Lebanon Valley |
| 8 | Alexander Clement | Wing Back | Williams |
| 9 | Stanley Burnham | Tail Back / Blocking Back | Harvard |
| 9 | Woodruff “Doc” Bruder | Back | West Virginia |
| 10 | Lou Smyth | Back | Centre College |
| 10 | Walter Sechrist | Guard/Tackle | Western Maryland |
| 11 | Rae Crowther | End | Colgate |
| 12 | William “Bill” Springsteen | Center | Lehigh |
| 13 | Berlin “Guy” Chamberlin | End | Nebraska |
| 14 | Joseph “Butch” Spagna | Guard | Lehigh |
| 14 | Milton O’Connell | End | Lafayette |
| 15 | Harry “Red” Seidelson | Tackle | Pittsburgh |
| 15 | Saville Crowther | Guard/Tackle | Colgate |
| 16 | Charles Carton | End | Holy Cross |
| 17 | William “Bill” Hoffman | Guard | Lehigh |
| 18 | Elmer McCormick | Center | Canisius |
| 18 | Arthur Harms | Tackle | Vermont |
| 18 | Jacob Kaufman | Tackle | Pennsylvania |
| 19 | James Welsh | Guard | Colgate |
| 19 | Clark Craig | End | Pennsylvania |
| 20 | Francis “Jug” Earp | Center/Tackle/Guard | Monmouth |
| Walter LeJeune | Guard/Center/Tackle/Back | Bethany College (West Virginia) |